PS Review of Freemasonry NEWS

Monday, June 24, 2013

The Prepared Heart: A Subconscious link to the Light of Masonry by Honorable John L. Hairston


There is an ancient consciousness to Freemasonry, an esoteric knowledge and operation of its principles that have been distributed through the ages under a plethora of  names and designations. This consciousness has been couched in the Ancient Mystery School systems of the earliest antiquity, vouchsafed by Divine Providence and transferred to subsequent generations as a supplement to the Indivisible Purpose embedded in the quintessence of Humanity and Creation.

It is a prerequisite of every candidate of Freemasonry to have a belief in a Supreme Being and come to the doors of the Craft of their own Free will and accord. When in proper alignment, these two requirements are amalgamated in a harmonious mission of drawing each TRUE CANDIDATE to the threshold of their conception and nascency.

Our belief in a Supreme Being will lead us to the logical conclusion that this Supreme Being has invested us with a Purpose from birth to eternity. It is equally understood that all of life's trials, tests, accomplishments and failures serves as supports that assist us in reaching and attaining that Purpose. The principles that evolve from these life lessons are supplements to the Divine revelation provided us from the Supreme Architect of the Universe. These supplemental principles can be found in various forms and vehicles, freemasonry being one of such. It is Creative Fate and the government of Universal Law that we encounter the opportunity to obtain these supplemental principles so vital to the unfoldment of the Original and Divine Purpose inherent in us.

The lecture asks, where were we FIRST Prepared; the answer is IN THE HEART. But, what is the lecture drawing us to? To an ancient knowledge of the Law of Attraction.

Because the principles within the body of Freemasonry are supplements to the knowledge and unfoldment of the Purpose of Man, they are co-joined to the seed that IS the Purpose of Man. So, when one comes into contact with a sign, symbol, object, word, or regalia of Freemasonry-although they may have no conscious knowledge of either, they are subconsciously impacted and drawn to it, because it serves as an intricate part of their unfolding and IMPROVEMENT (the Journey).

The result is an intuitive and subconscious search and seeking for the Principles and Supplements to their Purpose that is contained within the sign, symbol, object, word, or piece of regalia. This begins to prepare the heart (SOUL) of man for the full encounter with the spirit of Freemasonry embedded right beneath the surface of the ritual and ceremonies. This preparation is a burning that draws us to the doors of Freemasonry that we may be able to possess the keys that unlock the doors to our development and progression into an eternal journey.

Let me be clear, every person knocking on the doors of Freemasonry are NOT TRUE CANDIDATES, they may become members, but only the TRUE INITIATES attain the sublime objective and spirit invested in the Craft. Not all come to the doors FIRST PREPARED IN THEIR HEARTS. They are drawn by the superficial components offered by the fraternity and organization. Some go years traveling in the Craft never to encounter nor attain the SUBLIME SECRETS OF THEIR MAGNANIMOUS EMERGENCE AND PURPOSE; they remain card holding members, never truly improving nor progressing to the Ultimate mark and chief objective-An Ever Evolving Perfection.

That Preparation in the heart is the light that led them through the vicissitudes of a dark world, to the flicker of the burning tapers at the outer door of the lodge, urging them to request entry thereby becoming united with the necessary tools to transform a rough existence into a perfection of purpose.

There are traits to the TRUE CANDIDATES of the Prepared heart that came to the doors of Freemasonry, drawn by the burning desire to obtain the tools and necessities that will bring in to view the latent possibilities within, that it may emerge into a resplendent illumination of one who has tapped into the operative harmony of that which composes the COMPLETE MAN.

It is this burning heart, prepared by Divine Providence, that we bear into immortality to carry the witness of our compliance to the SUPREME MASTER'S INSTRUCTION. So Mote It Be.

For any questions concerning any portion of this and other postings contact: johnhairston357@gmail.com

ALSO PLEASE TAKE TIME TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE QUILL AND THE SWORD AT THE RIGHT HAND SIDE OF THE PAGE, SO YOU CAN BE NOTIFIED OF ALL NEW POSTINGS FOR THIS ONLINE MASONIC EDUCATIONAL VEHICLE. Visit our Facebook page as well:

Sunday, June 16, 2013

The Prince Hall Commission on Clandestine Masonry, 1961

I am sharing the Report of the Prince Hall Commission on Clandestine Masonry, which was given to United Supreme Council, A.A.S.R. of Freemasonry, Prince Hall Affiliation, Northern Jurisdiction, U.S.A., Inc. at Chicago, Illinois, May 1961, and the same report given to Conference of Grand Masters of Prince Hall Masons of America at Seattle, Washington, same month and year.

Many of the principles set out in the Report apply to even this day, in which we still the problem with Clandestine Masonry rampant in the America and abroad. This is presented for the Masonic world that they may read and know the efforts of the Prince Hall organization to do our part in resolving an issue in the Craft since the inception of the Grand Lodge system in England. And now, I present the Report:

















Please do not forget to subscribe to the Quill and the Sword. Look to the top right hand side of the Blog page and enter your email, and receive notification of new articles posted.
Also, check us out on Facebook and like the new Quill and Sword page:
Official Quill and Sword Facebook page

The Quill and the Sword team are working hard to bring you more educational and informational pieces through various genres of Media, stay tuned, we have just gotten warmed up...
Brother John L. Hairston
J. C. Logan Lodge #53, F. & A.M.
MWPHGL of WA. and Jurisdiction

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Washington State and the Charge Against Clandestine Freemasonry pt. 5

The Masonic Community Monitor, April 1999, front page 

We continue this series of articles with the years 1990-1999. I will begin this by citing a quote from part 4:"Beginning in 1986, we find that Past Grand Master, MW Charles Stubblefield prophetic, in that we discover, in the 1986-89 Proceedings, no significant entry by the Committee on Non-Prince Hall masons. There was a report given in 1986, but orally. From 1987-99, we find NO REPORT, and NO COMMITTEE."[1]

According to the 1989 Proceedings of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington, in the  listing of Official Correspondences of Past Grand Master, MW Kenneth Swannigan, written January 31, 1989:

"To: P.G.M. James W. Davis (Non-Prince Hall Commission); Re-directing the commission focus on attempts to resolve the issue(s) between Prince Hall Masons and the Sons-of-Haiti."[2]

So, we are surprised to find that there is no references to the Commission on Non-Prince Hall Masons, and no other reports concerning any activities of Clandestine Masonry but the report of the Grand Master (Kenneth Swannigan) on the Conference of Grand Masters, 1990, which he stated:

"There appears to be some concerns expressed that we, Prince Hall Masons, should be making more progress towards bringing Afro-American Non-Prince Hall Masons into the fold. While I support the concept of total fraternal relationship and brotherhood, it is clear that the wounds that separate us as Prince Hall and Non-Prince Hall Masons are deeper, infectious and will require more time to heal."[3]

In 1991 we still find no reference to the Commission or any report of the Commission. Yet in 1992, we find Past Grand Historian, WB Clemon L. Modisett presenting the following:
pg. 79, 1992 Grand Historian Report, MWPHGL of WA[4]
pg. 80, 1992 Grand Historian Report, MWPHGL of Wa

There were no other reports until the year 1997, where we find the full report on the Sons-of-Haiti[5], and the beginning of the process to absorb the group that had been since the 60's:
pg.113, 1997 Proceedings,  Report on Sons-of-Haiti
pg. 114, 1997 Proceedings,  Report on Sons-of-Haiti
pg. 115, 1997 Proceedings,  Report on Sons-of-Haiti
pg. 116, 1997 Proceedings,  Report on Sons-of-Haiti

Even without the 1998 Proceedings we still find significant activity for the year in the form of the Official Correspondence of the Grand Master, begin with a December 8th letter written from MW William C. Rheubottom to Bro. Russell Smith, regarding a proposal to absorb the Sons-of-Haiti[6]. This continues with more correspondence proposing actions to finalize a process that seemed to take  almost 30 years to complete:

"Feb. 3 (1998) To All Past Most Worshipful Grand Masters, re: Notification of healing ceremony for the former Sons-of-Haiti organization.[7]"

This was followed up by a February 27th Correspondence to the Jurisdiction that announced a "healing ceremony of the former Sons-of-Haiti.[8]" We know that ALL of the members of the Sons-of-Haiti members were healed based on the March 23rd letter sent to "The Skeleton Group of Sons of Haiti" that warned them about illegally operating as Sons-of Haiti Grand Lodge in Washington.[9] There were also 1999 Correspondences of January 30th, placing the former Sons-of-Haiti into Headquarters Lodge #75[10]. April 19th an Edict went out declaring the healing of the Sons-of-Haiti. Those members that were healed became a Lodge under dispensation designated as "Perseverance Lodge U.D." under the supervision of  DAL Kenneth Anthony, who visited, advised and monitored the newly healed lodge for 60 days.[11]This mentorship proved valuable, it was in the 1999 Annual Communication that Perseverance Lodge UD received its charter, and was now Perseverance lodge #103[12]:

 pg. 81, 1999 Proceedings of MWPHGL of WA
pg. 82, 1999 Proceedings of MWPHGL of Wa

Perseverance Lodge gained all the rights and privileges of all regular and recognized lodges worldwide. Perseverance Lodge #103 is still operating and in good standing to this day. Later in the 1999 Proceedings we find the full report on the Sons-of-Haiti[13]:
pg. 85, 1999 Proceedings report on the Sons-of-Haiti
pg. 86, 1999 Proceedings report on the Sons-of-Haiti

So, 1999 ends with a strong lodge being added to the fold, and the Jurisdiction ridding itself of another clandestine group. We will continue the next part going from 2000-the present. be sure to check out the other 4 parts to this series. And be sure to subscribe to receive notifications of new posts to the blog.

End notes:
1. Washington State and the Charge Against Clandestine Masonry Pt. 4, Honorable John L. Hairston, May 24th, 2013 entry.

2. Proceedings of the 86th Annual Communication of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1989, Official Correspondences of the Grand Master, pg. 17 

3. Proceedings of the 87th Annual Communication of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1990, Grand Master's Address, pg. 6

4. Proceedings of the 89th Annual Communication of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1992, Grand Historian's Report, pg. 79-80

5. Proceedings of the 94th Annual Communication of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1997, Annual Report of the Special Commission on the Sons-of-Haiti, pg. 113-116

6. Proceedings of the 96th Annual Communication of the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1999, Official Correspondences of the Grand Master, pg. 23

7. Ibid., pg. 24

8. Ibid., pg. 24

9. Ibid., pg. 25

10. Ibid., pg. 28

11. Ibid., pg. 27

12. Ibid., pg. 81-82

13. Ibid., pg. 85-86

Friday, May 24, 2013

Washington State and the Charge Against Clandestine Masonry Pt. 4

Image taken from the Washington listing of Bogus Grand Lodges (Phylaxis Society website)

In this portion, we will look into the decade of the 80s, and how the Most Worshipful Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington continued the fight against "clandestine masonry" in the State.

The year 1980 opens with MW Jimmy Simmons as Grand Master and Brother James T. Smith at the helm of the Committee on Non-Prince Hall Masons. Although the 1980 Proceedings doesn't list the Committee among the Appointed Committees[1], The Committee does report to the Grand Lodge[2], citing that the findings "in regards to the status of Non-Prince Hall Masons-meaning (black) still is of grave concerns to the Prince Hall family" in 1980.

According to the report, we find the origin of Union Lodge #43:

"This Grand Lodge gained a new Lodge as a result of its effort in Court. Namely Union Lodge #43, which still is operating and in good standing."[3]

Committee Chairman, James T. Smith noted that there was still the operation of the Sons of Haiti in Seattle as well, and gave a solution of following "the Creed of a Master Mason to combat Non-Prince Hall Masons."

In 1981, according to the Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons in 1982, The Sons of Haiti intensified their efforts in recruitment. They had begun sending letters out to members of the Prince Hall Jurisdiction with a return address of the Prince Hall Grand Lodge Masonic Hall[4]:

pg. 61, 1982 Proceedings



As you can see in the above excerpt, they were using the address of the Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington. Chairman James T. Smith also stated that they were bold enough to send a letter of recruitment to the, then, Sovereign Grand Commander of the N. M. J. United Supreme Council, A.A.S.R., Ill. Russell S. Gideon, an ardent soldier against bogus masonry, and past Chairman of the Commission on Clandestine Masonry. The difference being that they used their own address on his letter.

The Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons of 1982 went on to cite and give place to, an article written by the Past Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Oregon, Dr. Otto C. Hagmeier, who delved into the questions of Negro Masonry and the prejudices of White Lodges and Grand Lodges to objectively deal with the question of our legitimacy. James T. Smith touched on the history of Alpha Lodge No. 116, and how abolitionists secured the Charter for Alpha Lodge No. 116 based on their desire to admit Negroes to Lodges, who previously were rejected by White Lodges based on their color. Who also, after securing the charter, admitting and properly giving the reins to the Negroes, attempted to petition the Grand Lodge of New Jersey for a charter to form a lodge, but were refused and had to re-affiliate themselves with Alpha Lodge under the leadership of Negro Masons.

According to the 1982 report, many of the Lodges were suffering from dwindling membership:
pg. 63, 1982 Proceedings[5]


These strategies were also offered as a defensive effort to thwart clandestine masonry:

"1. Remember court decision 1959-1962[6].
 2. Remember George E. Bushnell, former Chief Justice of Supreme Court of Michigan appeared as a witness and testified in New York-Prince Hall[7].
 3. Educate those who show interest-don't argue-because it [won't] change point of view.
 4. Review Phylaxis Society Pamphlets.
 5. Most of all read, research, and remember what you learned."[8]

In addition to the Report submitted by the Committee, the Grand Lodge received a report that extended further the subject of Bogus masonry, from the pen of the Grand Historian, WB Clemon L. Modisett, who stated:

"In the matter of non-Prince Hall Masons. The record shows that the fight against these men, in this Jurisdiction, is as old as the Jurisdiction itself."[9]

This report from the Grand Historian is packed with information. Because many of the readers of the Quill and the Sword are actively involved in research of Bogus bodies, I will post excerpts of importance to those researchers, and Washington State Masons specifically.

Brother Modisett goes into a journey, much like my own, concerning the confrontation of Clandestine masonry in the State, beginning in 1906:
 

Excerpt from the 1906 Proceedings of MW Grand Lodge of Washington and Oregon[10]

Brother Modisett continues the Report with an incident in Portland, Oregon, where a bogus group attempted to invade the territory of the young Grand Lodge and Grand Master Payne had them jailed[11]:
pg. 75, 1982 Proceedings[12]

We are then informed of the silence concerning the activity of bogus bodies in Washington State in the 20s and 30s:
pg. 75, 1982 Proceedings

There was a portion of the report that I believe that all researchers and students on Bogus bodies would find of significance, the testimony of the "grand master" of the Universal Grand Lodge (Washington), Johnny T. Washington [please note how the line of questioning by the attorney for the MWPHGL of WA, would later come back to haunt him:
pg. 77, 1982 Proceedings[13]
pg. 78, 1982 Proceedings

Please direct you attention to Johnny T. Washington's answer to the question as to the legitimacy of the John A. Bell group, he stated:

"After we investigated the John A. Bell Lodge-The Prince Hall Lodge-I knew about them-after I found out that the John A. Bell Lodge didn't have Masonic affiliation and no Supreme Council, and the man who first set it up was suspended from our Supreme Lodge, and all the work that he did after that was declared to be not legitimate work, I didn't need to pay attention to them at all."

Johnny T. Washington was purporting that John A. Bell was suspended from Universal Grand Lodge, and considered clandestine by Universal Grand Lodge based on his work AFTER being suspended. This was both interesting and hypocritical, because in the same testimony, Johnny T. Washington claimed that Universal grand Lodge claimed lineage through John G. Jones, and there was AMPLE evidence to his being EXPELLED from Masonry by the Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Illinois in 1903, yet they received their origin from HIM?! By his own testimony, he declared his own Grand Lodge clandestine ON THE RECORD!

Brother Modisett continues to point out the contentions of both groups against Prince Hall[14]:
pg. 78, 1982 Proceedings 

Can you believe it? John A. Bell would claim their lineage to the white Grand Lodge Massachusetts and Pennsylvania. Yet, they would also cite five, COUNT THEM, Five WARRANTS OF CONSTITUTION. If either of the Grand Lodges of Cuba, San Domingo, Haiti or South Africa were REGULAR, deriving said Constitution from the Grand Lodges of Massachusetts or Pennsylvania, then why would they need five different ones? why not secure one? Ridiculous....

Universal Grand Lodge claimed their lineage through John G. Jones (expelled mason), whom they claim received a charter from Romania or France? this has long been refuted as there is sufficient evidence to prove that the "charter" was truly ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION from the State of Illinois, who has NO POWER to set up Grand Lodges.

Brother Modisett then provided a detailed listing of the argument in support of the judgement:

pg.79, 1982 Proceedings[15]


I can not report 1983, due to the lack of the proceeding, but will continue with 1984, with MW Charles Stubblefield as Grand Master, and no citing of Committee on Non-Prince Hall masons. This can be attributed to the some sort of languishing of the Grand Lodge to pursue the issue, as cited by the Grand Master in his Annual Address; which turns out to be the ONLY report on Non-Prince Hall Masons for 1984:

"They are still in this state and many other states. Our only problem is, and will be, our complacency. When we get that feeling that just because we are Prince Hall Masons and we are secure and need not tell the whole Prince Hall story, then the roof will cave in. So, my Brothers, live as Prince Hall Masons should and publicize our deeds of what we do for all to see, and you will draw them to you"[16] 

So, I pronounce the same in this day too all of the Prince Hall historians, researchers, and defenders of our Legacy against Clandestine activity, continue to progress and fight, there is NO TIME TO BE COMPLACENT.

The statement issued in 1984, by Grand Master, Charles Stubblefield, had an instant impact, because in 1985 the Committee on Non-Prince Hall Masons was back with a report, and the Official Acts of the Grand Master cited several meetings with Grand Lodge of Washington (white) attorneys to discuss the issue of clandestine masonry. Grand Master Stubblefield reported[17]:
 pg. 11, Grand Master's Address 1985

Chairman James T. Smith reported that the Sons of Haiti had become a "thorn in the side" of the Grand Lodge here in the State of Washington. During the year of 1984, the year of complacency, the Sons of Haiti had picked up their solicitation of Prince Hall member, sending such solicitation to even the Grand Master of the Prince Hall Grand Lodge. Despite the burning of their building and the disunity in their ranks, they still managed to send letters of solicitations as well as offer to rent the Grand Lodge building for their affairs. They even published in The Facts newspaper, an advertisement to the following:
pg. 67, 1985 Proceedings
pg. 68, 1985 Proceedings

This particular history will be traced in another article, but I can tell you that the only Lodge (out of the three) that had a traceable history was the Evergreen State Lodge. They can be traced back to the Supreme Council of Louisiana,  although said Supreme Council of Louisiana isn't recognized as a legitimate Supreme Council for the main reason of conferring the Craft degrees (1st-3rd) are supposed to be under the Jurisdiction of the Blue House and a Grand Master/Grand Lodge.

Beginning in 1986, we find that Past Grand Master, MW Charles Stubblefield prophetic, in that we discover, in the 1986-89 Proceedings, no significant entry by the Committee on Non-Prince Hall masons. There was a report given in 1986, but orally. From 1987-99, we find NO REPORT, and NO COMMITTEE.

Our next posting will be for the decade of the 90s, as it will prove to bear some of the most impactful events in Prince Hall history for Washington State.

For any questions concerning any portion of this and other postings contact: johnhairston357@gmail.com

ALSO PLEASE TAKE TIME TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE QUILL AND THE SWORD AT THE RIGHT HAND SIDE OF THE PAGE, SO YOU CAN BE NOTIFIED OF ALL NEW POSTINGS FOR THIS ONLINE MASONIC EDUCATIONAL VEHICLE. 


Endnotes:

1. Proceedings of the 77th Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1980, Appointed Committees, pgs. 19-21

2. Ibid. Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons, submitted by Bro. James T. Smith, pgs. 43-44

3. Ibid. Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons, pg. 44

4. Proceedings of the 79th Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1982, Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons, submitted by Bro. James T. Smith, pg. 63

5. Ibid. Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons, submitted by Bro. James T. Smith, pg. 63

6. This case can be reviewed in the Proceedings of the 58th Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1961, Official Report of the Commission on Clandestine Masonry, pgs. 72-80

7. [*80]  Among the witnesses called in behalf of plaintiffs was Judge George E. Bushnell, former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Michigan. After his retirement from the bench, Judge Bushnell, a thirty-third degree Mason, became "Sovereign Grand Commander" of "The Supreme Council of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite of Freemasonry ('White') of the Northern Jurisdiction." Judge Bushnell had been a Mason for over 50 years and has held various offices in the Scottish Rite bodies. His position in Masonry fully qualified him as an expert in Masonic affairs. 

8. Proceedings of the 79th Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1982, Report on Non-Prince Hall Masons, submitted by Bro. James T. Smith, pgs. 63-64

9. Ibid. Report of the Grand Historian, submitted by WB Clemon L. Modisett, pg.74-80

10. Proceedings of the 3rd Annual Communication of the M. W. Grand Lodge of Washington and Oregon, A. F. & A.M., 1906, Resolutions on Irregular Masonry, pg. 21-22

11. Proceedings of the 9th Annual Communication of the M. W. United Grand Lodge, F. & A.M. of the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1912, Grand Master's Address, [no pg. number]

12. Proceedings of the 79th Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1982, Report of the Grand Historian, submitted by WB Clemon L. Modisett, pg.75

13. Ibid. Report of the Grand Historian, submitted by WB Clemon L. Modisett, pg.77-78

14. Ibid., pg. 78

15. Ibid., pg. 79

16. Proceedings of the 81st Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1984, Grand Master's Address, pg. 8

17. Proceedings of the 82nd Annual Communication of the M. W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge, F. & A.M., for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1985, Grand Master's Address, pg. 11

18. Ibid., Report on Non Prince Hall Masons, submitted by Chrm. James T. Smith, pgs. 65-69

19. Ibid., Report on Non Prince Hall Masons, pg. 68


Friday, May 17, 2013

Confusion in the Craft: Necessity in Achieving Ritual Uniformity by Honorable John L. Hairston, J. C. Logan Lodge #53 MWPHGL of WA


Book of Instruction of the MWPHGL of Wa and its Jurisdiction

After attending an EA work at Egyptian Lodge #44 in Tacoma, Wa, I thought hard about an important point identified by a newly initiate EA, as he was given an opportunity to address the Craft. Without fear he stated that he recognized stark differences in the way the degree was worked, by two different Lodges in the SAME Jurisdiction, and it WAS CONFUSING. His statement was innocent, but placed a resounding issue before the Craft. Is this the results we are trying to achieve in the Jurisdiction? Our newly made masons confused as to which is the correct or real way to work?

It was my intent (and still is) to write a piece on the ritual development of the Book of Instruction for the Washington (Prince Hall) Jurisdiction, and saw the young Mason's point as an opportunity to introduce the idea of addressing Ritual Uniformity; its attempts, efforts and history to be achieved in the Prince Hall Jurisdiction of Washington State.

The concept of Ritual uniformity isn't new at all, it has been a constant pursuit in the Craft since its inception. Bro. C. F. W. Dyer, in his Prestorian Lecture for 1973[1] informs:

"There had no doubt been attempts at various times before the Union [1813: author added] to secure uniformity of working, but it seems unlikely that they were particularly successful. In the Grand Lodge under the Duke of Atholl, the Nine Worthies were appointed to secure general uniformity but their employment seemed to die out. In considering control under the premier Grand Lodge, the work of William Preston, after whom this Lecture is named, very quickly commends the attention. His Illustrations of Masonry indicates his intense interest in instruction in Craft Ritual procedures. In the 1790s, after his re-instatement in the Craft by the premier Grand Lodge, it is more than probable that the Ritual procedures which he taught, as well as the system of teaching them, were to some degree of his own devising, By the early 1800s his medium for instruction was a Lodge of Instruction associated with the Lodge of Antiquity and his method was through Lecture in question and answer form."


We find this same rally by the Committee on Jurisprudence, for Ritual procedure and uniformity, at the very onset of the constitution of the Grand Lodge of A. F. and A. M., for the State of Washington and Oregon in the First Annual Communication:

"Our Grand Master's suggestion that we adopt the use of the Ritual now in use by the Illinois Jurisdiction and others not approved. Until such time as we adopt a STANDARD [emphasis mine] work of our own, we should hesitate to use others. Uniformity is desired in the ritualistic ceremonies in this jurisdiction and your Committee views with alarm the adoption of any exposed work whatever. We recommend the adoption of a lecture system based upon the old English method and the Masonic Carpet. We further recommend that the use of Richardson's Monitor in any lodge room or among any of our brethren by strictly forbidden."[2]


MW PGM J. C. Logan made the recommendation based on the fact that all of the Lodges were in use of the Ritual and Work of Illinois[3]. According to the Proceedings of the Second Annual Communication, in 1905, the Committee of Jurisprudence chose the Ecci Oreinti as the standard work for the Jurisdiction:

"After investigation we find that the Ecci Orienti is the most generally accepted Ritual, and used almost entirely throughout the United States and all together in England. It is a work that a Mason need not keep under lock and key for the reason that the profane cannot read its contents."
[4]

I want to divert for a moment to educate the Craft of some misconceptions concerning the "Ecci Orienti" and its origins. For many Prince Hall masons, the Ecci Orienti is what is designated, "The Black Book", a small, pocket-sized, hard-covered booklet which contains the Opening and Closing, as well the Work for the Blue Lodge Craft degrees. Ask further concerning, and you will be told that it also called the "Nizzardini" based on the "alleged" author of the Ritual.

 The "Nizzardini" front page
And, they will believe that the Ecci Orienti spoken of in the Report of the Committee on Jurisprudence in 1905 is one and the same "Nizzardini" Ritual they used up to two (2) years ago. But, upon further research we find that the "Nizzardini" was copyrighted in 1951:
The Nizzardini Copyright date and Index


In fact, a search for Anthony Nizzardini on ancestry.com produced an obituary that gives his birth date as September 13, 1913, in New York City[5]. So, how could Anthony Nizzardini, who was born in 1913, be the author of a Ritual adopted by the MW Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington in 1905?

If we return to the Report of the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence (1905), they stated that the Ecci Orienti could not be read by the profane, this means it was a Cipher. The Nizzardini is not a cipher, but there is an Ecci Orienti that predates the "Nizzardini" by 81 years:
The Ecci Orienti of 1870

The Ecci Oreinti was authored by Moses Wolcott Redding and published through his Masonic Supply Company, much like Anthony Nizzardini did. The 1870 Ecci Orienti is a cipher. Both Redding and Nizzardini were living in New York as well as Masons. It is highly probable that the "Nizzardini" Ritual is a revision of the 1870 Ecci Orienti authored by Redding. And, it very much likely that the 1870 Ecci Orienti is the one spoken of in the 1905 Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence report.

Continuing the historical examination of Ritual uniformity, the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence submitted this report to the Grand Lodge at the Third Annual Communication in 1906[6]:
1906 Committee on Jurisprudence Report, pg. 35
1906 Committee on Jurisprudence Report, pg. 36



It is important to note that the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence was encouraging the use of NO BOOKS in open lodge; the open ritual in an open Lodge was called, "exposed work", and was adamantly discouraged. Secondly, we still find the Grand Lodge looking for an established "uniform system" of ritual. In 1919 Book of Laws, compiled by then Code Commissioner, PGM E. H. Holmes:

Book of Laws 1919, Washington

We find Article VII Section, declaring as Law:

"Section 1. The Work and lectures of this Grand Lodge adopted in the annual communication, July, 1909, shall be the STANDARD [emphasis mine] work of the jurisdiction, and EVERY LODGE SHALL ADOPT AND PRACTICE THE SAID WORK [my emphasis] and lectures, and NO OTHER. And any lodge violating the provisions of this section without express authority from the Grand Lodge, shall be subject to discipline"[7]

We readily identify the priority that the forefathers of the Grand Lodge placed on the Uniformity of Ritual Work throughout the Jurisdiction. Yet, here in 2013, we have an EA stating that there is an obvious variation of methods and performances of the Ritual in the Jurisdiction; how and when did this diversion from uniformity to dissonance begin?

After reviewing the 1961, 1973, 1977, 1991, and 2004 Codes, we found no direct allusion to Ritual and Work as we did in the 1906 and 1913 Codes. I then began to search the Proceedings after 1913, to see if any references could be made to Ritual and Work, and if there were any Code changes to the Work and Lectures section of the Code. According to the Proceedings in my possession, we find that the diversion from uniformity started early than 1942; In the Proceedings of the 39th Annual Communication we read in the Report of the Grand Lecturer:

1942 Grand Lecturer report by RW W. H. LaBelle, pg. 26



The Grand Lecturer proposed a uniformed and standard Ritual for the Jurisdiction, this was due to what he explained as the jurisdiction not having a "uniform work of their own"[8]. He attempted to craft a uniformed ritual, but due to mistakes, he would have to make corrections. This was done and sent to Past Grand Master C. W. Davis for review. The Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence referred the Report to the next Grand Session.



We pick back up in 1946, to find MW Grand Master Ernest J. Brown, referencing the January 21st-28th (1946) International Conference of Grand Masters, where talks commenced for the printing of a UNIVERSAL RITUAL for Prince Hall Jurisdictions[9]. the Committee on the Grand Master's Address referred the recommendation of the Universal Ritual to the Grand Lecturer, W. V. Scott, who reported that "much work is still needed to be done on this temporary manual of instruction."[10] It was cited that some semblance of Order and uniformity had been attained, and was considering a ciphered work, but felt that it would "disrupt" what had been attained in the way of uniformity. At this time we know from the listing of RW Grand Lecturer's Official Acts, that there were four proposed temporary manuals of instruction that had been handed over to Brother R. N. Bird.

By 1947, improvements had been made to the Manual of Instruction and placed in the hands of the several Worshipful Masters[11]. The 1947 Manual of Instruction contained only the Opening and Closing and no "ritualistic work". According to his Official Acts, 6 to 10 copies were sent to the Subordinate Lodges.

At the 1948 Annual Communication, the following Resolutions was adopted[12]:
1948 Resolutions adopted at the 45th Annual Communication, pg. 14


Thus, there would be a Standard Opening and Closing, and Ralph Lester's Look To the East would cover the Degree work. One would think that this uniformity would uniform the Jurisdiction and preserve the symmetry between the Lodges in Ritual work. Such standardization was to be short-lived, in 1949, the Committee on Resolutions would report the following:

"Be it unanimously resolved that Atlas Lodge No. 21 go on record to dispense with RW W. V. Scott's Temporary Manual of Instruction and Freemason's Guide, and return recognition to Lester's 'Look to the [East]'."[13]

And thus began the reemergence of the break from uniformity. This would continue until 1958, when we find for the first time, a Committee on Work and UNIFORMITY[14]. There was a referral to there Committee a  resolution on the Lester's Ritual (Page 2, Article f).

It be but one year later that the Committee on Work and Uniformity would disappear, and 1962 before the Grand Lecturer would recommend dispensing with Lester's "Look to the East", and adopting the "Nizzardini" (a revised version of the 1870 Ecci Orienti by M. W. Redding)[15]:
1962 Resolution on Ritual Work

Although the Jurisdiction would find a standard ritual, it would not hinder the breach upon uniformity and the steady increase of innovation. It wouldn't be until 2004 that a standardization of Work would again appear in the Jurisdiction with the approval of a Manual of Instruction adopted at the 104th Annual Communication, with this statement on the inside cover:


We now have in the works standard Ritual book of Instruction which includes all Craft degree work as well, and despite the Jurisdictions efforts to establish Ritual Uniformity, in 2013 we find ourselves in a circumstance where innovation has created Confusion in the Craft.

The necessity of Uniformity in Ritual finds significance in the fact that it preserves the Jurisdiction from innovations and complacency. It better enables harmony between Lodges especially during visitation and there is need for visitors to fill places and stations. It would allow us know when there is a "foreigner" among us, and whether his work is of this Jurisdiction. I believe in the right of a Grand Lodge to choose its work, but I am also of the position that all subordinate Lodges under that Grand Lodge should work in ONE ACCORD. The observation of the young EA is a clarion call for the Jurisdiction to return to the UNIFORMITY and Standard of the Code and clear up the variations in our work. Have we not recognize the prophetic revelation in that the VSL says, "out the mouth of Babes (EAs) speaks the Truth", we should also reflect on the fact that the disharmony in the work is a result of compromising and laziness in the work, as well as mirror image of the harmony in the Jurisdiction itself. Let us heed with attentive ears the wise counsel of our young and repair the breach. I mean, what does the Ritual Book instruct us to do when there is Confusion in the Craft?


Endnotes:
1. In Search of Ritual Uniformity, A General Examination of the Regulation and Development of Craft Ritual Proceedings after 1813, Prestorian Lecture for 1973 (May 4,  1973) by Bro. C. F. W. Dyer. Section 2, Pre-Union and William Preston.

2. Proceedings of the First Annual Communication of the M.W. Grand Lodge of A. F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Oregon, 1904, Report of the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence, pg. 28

3. Proceedings of the First Annual Communication of the M.W. Grand Lodge of A. F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Oregon, 1904, Grand Master's Address, pg. 13

4. Proceedings of the Second Annual Communication of the M.W. Grand Lodge of A. F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Oregon, 1905, Report of the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence, pg. 52-53

5. Anthony Nizzardini obituary on the Pocono Record website: http://www.poconorecord.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050117/NEWS07/301179982

6. Proceedings of the Third Annual Communication of the M.W. Grand Lodge of A. F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Oregon, 1906, Report of the Committee on Masonic Jurisprudence, pg. 35-36

7. Book of Laws: Containing the Constitution and By-Laws of the M.W. United Grand Lodge, Free and Accepted Masons, The State of Washington and Jurisdiction, from 1903 A.L. 5903 to 1919 A.L. 5919, Inclusive. Compiled by M. W, E. H. Holmes, Code Commissioner.

8. Proceedings of the Thirty-Ninth Annual Communication of the M.W. United Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1942, Report of the Grand Lecturer, pg. 25

9. Proceedings of the Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1946, Grand Master's Address, pg. 5

10. Ibid.  Grand Lecturer's Report, pg. 29-34

11. Proceedings of the Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1947, Grand Lecturer's Report, pg. 35

12. Proceedings of the 45th Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1948, Resolutions, pg. 14

13. Proceedings of the 46th Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1949, Report of the Committee on Resolutions and Recommendations, pg. 38

14. Proceedings of the 55th Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1958, Report of the Committeee on Work and Uniformity, pg. 46

15. Proceedings of the 59th Annual Communication of the M.W. Prince Hall Grand Lodge of  F. & A.M. for the State of Washington and Jurisdiction, 1962, Resolution on Ritual Work, pg. 74